What goes around, comes around

  • Commentary
  • Consumer
  • RTI
  • Contact
Home » Some practical tips on RTI by Kerala SIC

Some practical tips on RTI by Kerala SIC

June 17, 2010 By videv Leave a Comment

From recent news, here are some interesting tips and practical information from Kerala State information commission about RTI applications they handle.

http://expressbuzz.com/cities/thiruvananthapuram/%E2%80%98be-specific-while-seeking-info-under-rti-act/178839.html

Number each document that you require under the Act.

Be brief as possible. Avoid long-winding explanations or irrelevant details.

Seeking a compiled report of the information or asking the information officer to fill in a prepared format is against the rules.

The Act empowers the public to examine or get attested copies of files,  documents and registers in the possession of public institutions.

Court Fee Stamp and Treasury Chalan will be accepted as application fee only in State Government offices.

In public sector units and Central Government institutions, the fee should be remitted directly or through DD/cheque.

Applicants hailing from the BPL category should enclose certificate issued by the Corporation or Municipal Secretary or the Block Development Officer for getting a fee exemption.  Ration cards will not be accepted.

Your subsequent appeals should not seek information different from the one asked for in your original application. `The cardinal rule is that be specific to the extent possible.

That will be ideal for both sides – the person seeking the information and the person giving it – and also the Information Commission,’’ State Chief Information Commissioner Palat Mohandas said.

“We had also noticed appellants including caustic and nasty remarks in their appeals,’’ he said.

I will take a few of the statements above and give my understanding on it:

Number each document that you require under the Act.

What it most likely means is that the applicant should ask for different information under different numbered points in the RTI application.  That will make it easier for both applicant and PIO to track what is being requested and replied.

Seeking a compiled report of the information or asking the information officer to fill in a prepared format is against the rules.

It is interesting that a SIC has issued this guideline.  This is perfectly correct according to RTI act.  One can ask for existing documents or information, whatever format they are normally or already in.  The compilation of information is not the job of PIO or to be done under RTI act.  The RTI applicant can compile it or prepare into a different format after receiving the ‘raw’ documents and information.

Your subsequent appeals should not seek information different from the one asked for in your original application.

If applicants are doing it, then they are not following due process or not tracking their own original RTI applications in a disciplined way.  Moreover, it will not make job of PIO easier if an RTI applicant asks for different information in appeal, and may only delay things for the RTI applicant.  One should file a new RTI for new information.

We had also noticed appellants including caustic and nasty remarks in their appeals

That is not going to help anybody, is it!

Filed Under: RTI



Related Posts

  1. RTI template for Karnataka State
  2. Points from RTI Discussion on 9th May
  3. PIO can charge fees only according to Fee and Cost Rules
  4. Discussion points of first RTI Session in L B Shastri Nagar
  5. Judiciary needs to take RTI seriously

videv

Connect With Me :

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To prevent spam bots, pls enter answer below! * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.

DOWNLOAD FREE eBook PDF: Surviving the Legal Jungle

Surviving-the-Legal-Jungle-Cover-Image

Contact me

Contact me for any queries on RTI or Consumer (medical cases only) related issues

Recent Posts

  • Aarogya Setu app – How it works and handles Data Privacy, Upload, Storage, and Deletion
  • Download Motor Vehicles Act and Rules including 2019 amendments with higher traffic fines and penalties (bare acts)
  • How to file Execution affidavit after winning consumer forum case if opposite party does not obey court order
  • Tata Sky has a major service outage since Mar 11, 2015
  • How to file a consumer court/forum complaint in Delhi

Popular Posts

  • How to file a consumer court complaint (in Bangalore) 178k views
  • Consumer forum/court template for Bangalore 36.6k views
  • Alternatives to use before filing consumer court complaint in India 27.5k views
  • How to file Execution affidavit after winning consumer forum case if opposite party does not obey court order 23.6k views
  • ICICI Bank: failure to login to internet banking is consistent for last 3-4 months! 12.7k views
  • Tatkal booking experience, tips, and lessons learnt 12.3k views
  • How to file RTI application for Income tax refund 10.7k views
  • Contact 9.4k views
  • Discussion points of first RTI Session in L B Shastri Nagar 6.6k views
  • Bare Act of RTI – Right to Information Act 2005 6.5k views

Recent Comments

  • videv on How to file Execution affidavit after winning consumer forum case if opposite party does not obey court order
  • TL on How to file Execution affidavit after winning consumer forum case if opposite party does not obey court order
  • videv on How to file Execution affidavit after winning consumer forum case if opposite party does not obey court order
  • Ajay D on How to file Execution affidavit after winning consumer forum case if opposite party does not obey court order
  • videv on How to file Execution affidavit after winning consumer forum case if opposite party does not obey court order

Category Specific RSS

All Topics
RTI
Consumer
Commentary

On Facebook

Vivek Deveshwar

Copyright 2005-2017 · Privacy Policy · Log in

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy